About Legacy Tire & Auto Repair

Our Story

Legacy Tire & Auto Repair – Carrying the Tradition Forward

Welcome to Legacy Tire & Auto Repair, your trusted source for automotive service and tire needs on the Westside of Youngstown, OH! While our name is new, our roots run deep in this community.

A New Chapter with a Rich History

We officially launched as Legacy Tire & Auto Repair in April 2025, marking an exciting new stand-alone venture. However, our team has been serving Youngstown drivers at this location since 1978. That means we bring more than 45 years of combined experience and local expertise to every vehicle we service!

Building a Legacy of Trust from Day One

Legacy Tire & Auto Repair was founded on a commitment to community, integrity, and long-term growth. Our journey has already earned recognition from Modern Tire Dealer, a respected national voice in the tire industry, reinforcing our dedication to delivering reliable, high-quality automotive service.

Meet the Family Behind the Legacy

Automotive excellence is a family affair for us. Rich and his wife Mary Rogenski, along with their son and daughter-in-law, Brian and Colleen Rogenski, are proud to own and operate Legacy Tire & Auto Repair.

We are committed to continuing the tradition of quality service, community involvement, and a deeply rooted commitment to our loyal customers, both now and for generations to come.

Commitment to the Future

Breaking away to form Legacy Tire & Auto Repair has allowed us to make significant investments to better serve the modern driver. You’ll notice the difference right away:

Modernized Facility: Our building has undergone a fantastic facelift and features our new colors and logo.
Next-Generation Tools: We’ve invested in much-needed new equipment and diagnostic tools to expertly service today’s complex cars and trucks.
Fairer Pricing: We have implemented a new pricing strategy that is far more fair and transparent for our valued customers.

Book An Appointment

Our Core Values

Driven by Expertise & Trusted by Locals

Everything we do is guided by a set of unwavering principles. When you choose Legacy Tire & Auto Repair, you can expect the following and more!

Integrity & Honesty

We'll always recommend only the services you truly need.

Transparency

Clear explanations and up-front communication about your vehicle.

Commitment

To your safety, your satisfaction, and the Youngstown community.

Innovation

Utilizing modern technology and methods for the best service.

Old-Fashioned Ethic

Delivering hard work and quality craftsmanship in everything we do.

Testimonials

See What Our Customers Say

“I’ve taken my vehicle here twice now, and they have always been amazing. they don’t bs you, and they are honest about what needs done and what could maybe wait till next time. they have made getting maintenance done to my car so much easier. 10/10 would recommend! if Wayne and his crew aren’t there, neither am i🤷🏻‍♀️”

Gabriella Young .

“Service was great. Appointment was available quickly. I had my brakes done. Good service is not inexplicable. My only issue is an extra charge for using a debit card. I would certainly recommend them but make sure you are aware of the extra charge. Thanks for the great service.”

Michael McBride .

“Had my 2017 Ford f250 in the dealership twice and I did a bunch of work on my truck replacing front end parts but couldn't solve my death wobble issue. The guys at Legacy had it figured out day one! I'll definitely be a repeat customer! Thanks so much for the great service!”

Glenn Pupino .

“My husband brought my car in for me, for an alignment and front tires. The difference in how my car drives after I picked it up is incredible! They were unfathomably quick and efficient. They explained everything simply but not condescendingly! A very welcoming and personable business. All around an outstanding experience, we will definitely be back!”

Heather Fumerola .

“Went in for a wheel alignment. I knew there was something else wrong with my car. They broke it down into sections of what was wrong with pricing for each thing wrong and gave me the printout. Gave me a link to do a payment plan type. Overall fantastic, so very nice and efficient.”

Crystal Parker .

“I would definitely recommend Legacy tire and auto repair. They got my car in same day that I called and had it repaired very quickly! Everyone working there was so nice, Wayne helped me out and he was very thorough and very friendly. I will definitely be bringing my car back here.”

Dana Miles .

“Everyone at this business is polite and professional. They just replaced the tires and brakes on my daughter’s car. I was impressed with how quickly they got me in for an appointment after I called, and I actually met the mechanic who worked on my car when I picked it up. Their pricing is competitive, and Wayne, the service manager, was very helpful in finding the best deal on the best parts for my budget. I will definitely use this business for all my future car repair needs and will absolutely recommend them to anyone looking for honest and reliable car repair or maintenance services.

Melissa Steinbeck Jul 18, 2026

“My first visit here won’t be my last. The people I dealt with, Wayne and Tori were very knowledgeable and explained everything that needed to be done and future repairs. I was very impressed with them.”

Pam Lindley Jul 17, 2026

“No one likes paying to have work done to their vehicle, but I always know I can trust Rich & company to do the job right. They explain everything so that even a person with no car knowledge can understand and will gladly answer any question no matter how simple. Even when I have a big expense I always leave confident in their work and happy.”

Beyond 2Roads Jul 9, 2026

“On the turnpike, and had a serious clunking sound in front of the passenger side. We stopped into legacy, without an appointment, and they worked us right in. Also showed us a coupon booklet, which paid for itself in this visit. Turned out to be a bad motor mount! Not a repair that you want to ignore! Thank you for peace of mind!!”

Lynne Christman Jul 6, 2026

“We took our truck into Legacy Tire and Auto as an engine light came on. The Service Manager, Wayne, was very professional and quick to get us in for an appointment. After the initial inspection, Wayne was prompt in calling us to tell us what needed done: an oil change, a new manifold gasket and manifold bolts as the bolts previously put on the truck was not the right ones. Because Legacy Tire and Auto is our go to and trusted auto shop, we knew they would do an excellent job. Their auto technician, CJ, worked on our truck and did a great job getting it completed in a timely manner. Their prices are by far the best around and their customer service is the best.

Nancy Thomas Oct 30, 2025

See All Reviews

Write a Review